{
 "schema_version": "ga-contents/2.0",
 "ga": "23",
 "slug": "23",
 "served_id": "23",
 "section": "writings",
 "section_name": "Writings",
 "witnesses": {
  "catalog": {
   "kind": "file",
   "ref": "data/steiner/ga_catalog.yaml",
   "date": ""
  },
  "scorecard": {
   "kind": "file",
   "ref": "research/audits/2026-10-ga-completeness/scorecard.json",
   "date": "2026-10-21",
   "db": "search-2026-10-21b.db",
   "db_sha256": "01257d325bec9eef9c6fcf24e00afb520682445a1110d9f972e4ff095381b070"
  },
  "anthrowiki_de": {
   "kind": "url",
   "ref": "https://anthrowiki.at/GA_23",
   "note": "AnthroWiki's page for the volume"
  },
  "gv2022": {
   "kind": "pdf",
   "ref": "Rudolf Steiner Verlag, Gesamtverzeichnis 2022 (the publisher's catalog)",
   "extract": "data/steiner/witnesses/rsv_gv_2022_entries.json"
  },
  "ga_online": {
   "kind": "catalog",
   "ref": "the publisher's GA-Online title list, read 2026-10-19; metadata only",
   "extract": "data/steiner/witnesses/ga_online_2026-10-19.json"
  },
  "inhalt": {
   "kind": "file",
   "ref": "data/steiner/witnesses/ga_inhalt.json",
   "source": "epub",
   "source_path": "data/ga-verlag-de/raw-extracted/GA023.md",
   "sha256": "da3f0c22f5f12c439651a7551ff215b4396c06e1ae5814af5f34bc0d3fbc8b52",
   "edition_year": 1976
  },
  "german_source": {
   "kind": "file",
   "ref": "data/steiner/witnesses/german_sources.json",
   "folder": "GA023/German"
  },
  "imprint:GA023/AP1972": {
   "kind": "file",
   "ref": "data/steiner-ga/data/GA023/AP1972/00_toc.md",
   "sha256": "2519642fdfd74a9d362762a6859a1dc1a516e6f58173c78ba088e51fa1c36fe6"
  },
  "imprint:GA023/SCR2001": {
   "kind": "file",
   "ref": "data/steiner-ga/data/GA023/SCR2001/00_toc.md",
   "sha256": "8d602a7094e4b1aae687e02656816d2083f0a89ce22ba43c435031b01cff89cc"
  },
  "rsarchive:Books/GA023": {
   "kind": "url",
   "ref": "https://www.rsarchive.org/Books/GA023/",
   "sha256": "b9f800b3d491bfb682585a20e773480244c22673476d2e88f4ce81af682b49b0",
   "note": "the archive's index page for the volume (cached June 2026)"
  },
  "anthrowiki_en": {
   "kind": "url",
   "ref": "https://en.anthro.wiki/GA_23",
   "fetched_at": "2026-04-26T16:15:20.422803+00:00",
   "content_hash": "4b288fb9354e6d38d91e518166df062c",
   "note": "AnthroWiki's English page for the volume"
  },
  "publisher_codes": {
   "kind": "file",
   "ref": "data/steiner/publisher_codes.json"
  },
  "alignment": {
   "kind": "db",
   "ref": "~/data/build/search-2026-10-21b.db",
   "sha256": "01257d325bec9eef9c6fcf24e00afb520682445a1110d9f972e4ff095381b070",
   "extract": "data/steiner/witnesses/alignment_summary.json"
  },
  "blackboard": {
   "kind": "file",
   "ref": "site/api/blackboard.json",
   "date": "2026-10-21T23:20:03Z"
  }
 },
 "identity": {
  "title_de": {
   "value": "Die Kernpunkte der Sozialen Frage (1919)",
   "w": [
    "catalog"
   ]
  },
  "title_en": {
   "value": "The Threefold Social Order",
   "w": [
    "catalog"
   ]
  },
  "kind": {
   "value": "text",
   "w": [
    "catalog"
   ]
  },
  "status": {
   "value": "published",
   "w": [
    "catalog"
   ]
  },
  "first_edition_year": {
   "value": null,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "editio_princeps_until": {
   "value": null,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "isbn": [
   {
    "value": "3-7274-0230-X",
    "w": [
     "anthrowiki_de"
    ]
   },
   {
    "value": "978-3-7274-6061-6",
    "w": [
     "anthrowiki_de"
    ]
   },
   {
    "value": "978-3-7274-0232-7",
    "w": [
     "gv2022"
    ]
   },
   {
    "value": "978-3-7274-6062-3",
    "w": [
     "gv2022"
    ]
   },
   {
    "value": "978-3-7274-0232-6",
    "w": [
     "anthrowiki_de"
    ]
   }
  ],
  "editions": [
   {
    "edition": 6,
    "year": null,
    "pages": null,
    "title": "Die Kernpunkte der Sozialen Frage",
    "w": [
     "ga_online"
    ]
   },
   {
    "edition": 7,
    "year": null,
    "pages": null,
    "title": "Die Kernpunkte der Sozialen Frage",
    "w": [
     "ga_online"
    ]
   },
   {
    "edition": null,
    "year": 1976,
    "pages": null,
    "isbn": "3-7274-0230-X",
    "taschenbuch": "606",
    "w": [
     "anthrowiki_de"
    ]
   },
   {
    "edition": null,
    "year": 2022,
    "pages": null,
    "isbn": "978-3-7274-0232-6",
    "taschenbuch": null,
    "w": [
     "anthrowiki_de"
    ]
   }
  ],
  "leernummer_2022": {
   "value": false,
   "w": [
    "gv2022"
   ]
  },
  "planned_2022": {
   "value": false,
   "w": [
    "gv2022"
   ]
  },
  "notes": {
   "value": null,
   "w": [
    "catalog"
   ]
  },
  "earlier_edition": {
   "value": null,
   "w": [
    "catalog"
   ]
  },
  "earlier_edition_of": {
   "value": null,
   "w": [
    "catalog"
   ]
  }
 },
 "printed_contents": {
  "source": {
   "value": "epub",
   "w": [
    "inhalt"
   ]
  },
  "flags": [],
  "edition_year": {
   "value": 1976,
   "w": [
    "inhalt"
   ]
  },
  "units": [
   {
    "heading": "VORREDE UND EINLEITUNG ZUM 41. BIS 80. TAUSEND DIESER SCHRIFT",
    "date": null,
    "place": null,
    "kind": "text",
    "words": 3774,
    "pictures": 0
   },
   {
    "heading": "VORBEMERKUNGEN ÜBER DIE ABSICHT DIESER SCHRIFT",
    "date": null,
    "place": null,
    "kind": "text",
    "words": 1323,
    "pictures": 0
   },
   {
    "heading": "I DIE WAHRE GESTALT DER SOZIALEN FRAGE, ERFASST AUS DEM ...",
    "date": null,
    "place": null,
    "kind": "text",
    "words": 6245,
    "pictures": 0
   },
   {
    "heading": "II. DIE VOM LEBEN GEFORDERTEN WIRKLICHKEITSGEMASSEN LÖSUNGSVERSUCHE ...",
    "date": null,
    "place": null,
    "kind": "text",
    "words": 8097,
    "pictures": 0
   },
   {
    "heading": "III. KAPITALISMUS UND SOZIALE IDEEN",
    "date": null,
    "place": null,
    "kind": "text",
    "words": 11863,
    "pictures": 0
   },
   {
    "heading": "IV.INTERNATIONALE BEZIEHUNGEN DER SOZIALEN ORGANISMEN",
    "date": null,
    "place": null,
    "kind": "text",
    "words": 3674,
    "pictures": 0
   },
   {
    "heading": "V. ANHANG",
    "date": null,
    "place": null,
    "kind": "text",
    "words": 1292,
    "pictures": 0
   },
   {
    "heading": "Hinweise des Herausgebers",
    "date": null,
    "place": null,
    "kind": "apparatus",
    "words": 564,
    "pictures": 0
   }
  ],
  "units_total": 8,
  "words_printed": 36832
 },
 "german_served": {
  "status": {
   "value": "served",
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "via_earlier_edition": {
   "value": null,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "source": {
   "class": {
    "value": "mixed",
    "w": [
     "german_source"
    ]
   },
   "urls": [],
   "sha256": [
    {
     "value": "da3f0c22f5f12c43",
     "w": [
      "german_source"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "edition_years": {
    "value": 1976,
    "w": [
     "german_source"
    ]
   },
   "methods": [
    "epub"
   ],
   "extraction_dates": [
    "2026-10-18"
   ],
   "rsarchive_url": {
    "value": "https://www.rsarchive.org/Books/GA023/German/",
    "w": [
     "german_source"
    ]
   },
   "date_note": "unrecorded; scraped before April 2026",
   "epub": {
    "path": "data/ga-verlag-de/raw-extracted/GA023.md",
    "edition_year": 1976,
    "sha256": "fafb307f16a52be9bc495e5f917e89c532cae43717d46769fa9c83421932c0f5",
    "epub_file": "GA023.epub",
    "named_in_witness": true
   },
   "pdf": {
    "path": "data/ga-pdfs/raw/GA_023.pdf",
    "source_url": "https://odysseetheater.org/GA/Buecher/GA_023.pdf",
    "sha256": "a2ef28fc6d04dab0d4e9f354aa37d25d8cfb95fdd449deefb55d11d4575b4875",
    "fetched_at": "2026-04-24T16:43:08.062170+00:00",
    "named_in_witness": false
   },
   "header_language_note": null
  },
  "units_served": {
   "value": 7,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "units_printed": {
   "value": 7,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "missing": [],
  "extra": [
   {
    "key": "l05",
    "title": "Anhang: An das deutsche Volk und an die Kulturwelt!",
    "w": [
     "scorecard"
    ]
   }
  ],
  "not_taken": [],
  "words_served": {
   "value": 36336,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "de_vs_printed": {
   "value": {
    "ratio": 1.0,
    "band": "comparable",
    "note": null
   },
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "units_inside_window": {
   "value": 0,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "units_outside_window": {
   "value": 0,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "rights_per_unit": [],
  "two_voice": {
   "value": false,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "other_hand_units": {
   "value": 0,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "other_hand_words": {
   "value": 0,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "authorship_kinds": {},
  "record_type": {
   "value": null,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  }
 },
 "english": {
  "status": {
   "value": "served",
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "via": {
   "value": null,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "credit_class": {
   "value": "named_editions",
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "units_served": {
   "value": 7,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "words_served": {
   "value": 28824,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "en_vs_de": {
   "value": {
    "ratio": 0.79,
    "band": "watch",
    "note": "This witness is somewhat shorter than the original. Minor omissions or condensation are possible."
   },
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "missing_units": [],
  "served": [
   {
    "code": "AP1972",
    "served": true,
    "folder": "GA023/AP1972",
    "identity": null,
    "title_line": "The Threefold Social Order",
    "title": {
     "value": "The Threefold Social Order (1972)",
     "w": [
      "imprint:GA023/AP1972",
      "anthrowiki_en"
     ]
    },
    "publisher": {
     "value": "Anthroposophic Press",
     "w": [
      "anthrowiki_en"
     ]
    },
    "place": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "years": [
     1972
    ],
    "pages": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "translated_from": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "isbn": [],
    "cw": {
     "value": "23",
     "w": [
      "anthrowiki_en"
     ]
    },
    "introduction_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "revised_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "edited_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "contributors": [],
    "raw_lines": [
     {
      "raw": "The Threefold Social Order (1972), This volume is a presentation of Steiner's central ideas on the",
      "w": "imprint:GA023/AP1972"
     },
     {
      "raw": "• [Rudolf Steiner](Rudolf_Steiner): *The Threefold Social Order*. **CW 23**. Translation by Frederick C. Heckel. Anthroposophic Press 1972 [rsarchive.org](https://wn.rsarchive.org/GA/GA0023/English/AP1972/GA023_index.html)",
      "w": "anthrowiki_en"
     }
    ],
    "translators": {
     "value": [
      "Frederick C. Heckel"
     ],
     "w": [
      "imprint:GA023/AP1972",
      "anthrowiki_en"
     ]
    },
    "code_publisher": {
     "value": "Anthroposophic Press",
     "w": [
      "publisher_codes"
     ]
    }
   },
   {
    "code": "SCR2001",
    "served": true,
    "folder": "GA023/SCR2001",
    "identity": null,
    "title_line": "Basic Issues of the Social Question",
    "title": {
     "value": "Basic Issues of the Social Question (2001)",
     "w": [
      "imprint:GA023/SCR2001"
     ]
    },
    "publisher": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "place": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "years": [
     1919,
     2001
    ],
    "pages": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "translated_from": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "isbn": [],
    "cw": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "introduction_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "revised_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "edited_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "contributors": [],
    "raw_lines": [
     {
      "raw": "Basic Issues of the Social Question (2001), In the social ferment of postwar Europe in 1919, Steiner presented his ideas about reforming the basis of society in three fundamental, autonomous spheres: economic, political/rights, and cultural. For a short time he worked to bring his ideas into practical application but it soon became impossible to bring about a “threefold social order” and he withdrew from the outer work in this area. His ideas have been worked with over the decades since that time and have proved to be just as valid today as they were then. This volume is a presentation of Steiner's central ideas on the threefold nature of the social organism. Translation by Frank Thomas Smith.",
      "w": "imprint:GA023/SCR2001"
     }
    ],
    "translators": {
     "value": [
      "Frank Thomas Smith"
     ],
     "w": [
      "imprint:GA023/SCR2001"
     ]
    },
    "code_publisher": {
     "value": null,
     "w": [
      "publisher_codes"
     ]
    }
   }
  ],
  "known_not_served": [
   {
    "code": null,
    "served": false,
    "isbn": [
     {
      "value": "978-1948302166",
      "w": [
       "anthrowiki_en"
      ]
     }
    ],
    "rights": null,
    "title": {
     "value": "Toward a Threefold Society: Basic Issues of the Social Question",
     "w": [
      "anthrowiki_en"
     ]
    },
    "publisher": {
     "value": "Rudolf Steiner Publications",
     "w": [
      "anthrowiki_en"
     ]
    },
    "place": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "years": [
     2019
    ],
    "pages": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "translated_from": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "cw": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "introduction_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "revised_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "edited_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "contributors": [],
    "raw_lines": [
     {
      "raw": "• [Rudolf Steiner](Rudolf_Steiner), James D. Stewart (Editor), Frank Thomas Smith (Translator): *Toward a Threefold Society: Basic Issues of the Social Question*. ‎ Rudolf Steiner Publications 2019. ISBN 978-1948302166; eBook ",
      "w": "anthrowiki_en"
     }
    ],
    "translators": {
     "value": [
      "Frank Thomas Smith"
     ],
     "w": [
      "anthrowiki_en"
     ]
    }
   },
   {
    "code": null,
    "served": false,
    "isbn": [
     {
      "value": "978-1855840720",
      "w": [
       "anthrowiki_en"
      ]
     }
    ],
    "rights": null,
    "title": {
     "value": "Towards Social Renewal. Rethinking the Basis of Society",
     "w": [
      "anthrowiki_en"
     ]
    },
    "publisher": {
     "value": "Rudolf Steiner Press",
     "w": [
      "anthrowiki_en"
     ]
    },
    "place": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "years": [
     2000
    ],
    "pages": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "translated_from": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "cw": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "introduction_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "revised_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "edited_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "contributors": [],
    "raw_lines": [
     {
      "raw": "• [Rudolf Steiner](Rudolf_Steiner), Matthew Barton (Editor): *Towards Social Renewal. Rethinking the Basis of Society*. Rudolf Steiner Press 2000. ISBN 978-1855840720",
      "w": "anthrowiki_en"
     }
    ],
    "translators": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    }
   },
   {
    "code": null,
    "served": false,
    "isbn": [],
    "rights": null,
    "title": {
     "value": "Basic Issues of the Social Question",
     "w": [
      "anthrowiki_en"
     ]
    },
    "publisher": {
     "value": "Southern Cross Review",
     "w": [
      "anthrowiki_en"
     ]
    },
    "place": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "years": [
     2001
    ],
    "pages": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "translated_from": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "cw": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "introduction_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "revised_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "edited_by": {
     "value": null,
     "w": []
    },
    "contributors": [],
    "raw_lines": [
     {
      "raw": "• [Rudolf Steiner](Rudolf_Steiner): *Basic Issues of the Social Question*. Translated by Frank Thomas Smith. Southern Cross Review 2001 [rsarchive.org](https://wn.rsarchive.org/GA/GA0023/English/SCR2001/GA023_index.html)",
      "w": "anthrowiki_en"
     }
    ],
    "translators": {
     "value": [
      "Frank Thomas Smith"
     ],
     "w": [
      "anthrowiki_en"
     ]
    }
   }
  ]
 },
 "alignment": {
  "editions": {
   "AP1972": {
    "units": 7,
    "confidence": {
     "low": 7
    },
    "reasons": {
     "no_original_to_compare": 3,
     "count_diverges": 4
    },
    "beads": 0,
    "bead_confidence": {},
    "bead_methods": {},
    "bead_gaps_de": 0,
    "bead_gaps_en": 0,
    "w": [
     "alignment"
    ]
   },
   "SCR2001": {
    "units": 8,
    "confidence": {
     "low": 6,
     "medium": 1,
     "high": 1
    },
    "reasons": {
     "no_original_to_compare": 4,
     "beads:length": 2,
     "count_diverges": 2
    },
    "beads": 44,
    "bead_confidence": {
     "medium": 32,
     "high": 12
    },
    "bead_methods": {
     "length": 44
    },
    "bead_gaps_de": 0,
    "bead_gaps_en": 0,
    "w": [
     "alignment"
    ]
   }
  }
 },
 "pictures": {
  "printed": {
   "value": 0,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "markers_de": {
   "value": 0,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "markers_en": {
   "value": 0,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "files_served": {
   "value": 0,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "files_total": {
   "value": 0,
   "w": [
    "scorecard"
   ]
  },
  "blackboard_plates": {
   "value": 0,
   "w": [
    "blackboard"
   ]
  }
 },
 "quality": {
  "marks": [
   {
    "code": "english_watch",
    "text": "This witness is somewhat shorter than the original. Minor omissions or condensation are possible.",
    "w": [
     "scorecard"
    ]
   },
   {
    "code": "keys_not_comparable",
    "text": "The German and English units use different keys; gaps between them are not asserted.",
    "w": [
     "scorecard"
    ]
   }
  ],
  "known_defects": []
 },
 "gaps": [],
 "cite": {
  "text": "Rudolf Steiner, Die Kernpunkte der Sozialen Frage (1919) (GA 23), as served by anthroposophy.ai, https://anthroposophy.ai/ga/23/, register entry https://anthroposophy.ai/contents/23/, status as of 2026-10-21: German served; English editions AP1972, SCR2001.",
  "bibtex_url": "/contents/data/23.bib",
  "csl_url": "/contents/data/23.csl.json"
 },
 "as_of": "2026-10-21T23:27:36Z",
 "conflict_count": 0,
 "held_sections": []
}